I posted this to the National Journal Healthcare blog this afternoon:
Today’s New York Times article ”In Health Reform, a Cancer Offers an Acid Test” is the type of analysis and discussion that makes me shudder when I think of how easy it is to misuse the findings from proposed comparative effectiveness research when the focus is just cost. The Times has a chart comparing the average cost of the five types of treatment for prostate cancer. What is lacking is how each procedure impacts the life of the person receiving the treatment.
I propose that all those considering health care reform remember to take the perspective of the patient and health consumer. For each procedure what needs to be included as part of any cost or effective analysis there is also a new measure that takes into account consumer’s assessment of PAID (pain, absence from work, invasiveness of procedure, and disability.) for each procedure under consideration. Patients need more information but it is more than just cost of the procedure.
Showing posts with label health care costs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label health care costs. Show all posts
Wednesday, July 8, 2009
Thursday, January 1, 2009
Paying for our Resolutions for 2009
Now that we are in 2009 we need to find ways to pay for the health system we want.
How do we raise revenue or reduce costs? Here are seven areas to consider:
1. Increase the tax on tobacco and alcohol with proceeds going to health. (Disincentives for smoking, including citywide smoking bans, have been proven to work.)
2. Enforce clean air and clean water laws.
3. Make companies pay for health consequences of their actions.
4. Encourage widespread use of health information technology.
5. Use mobile phone/messaging systems to support consumers in managing their own health.
6. Reinvent the school nurse/clinic model.
7. Create luxury taxes with proceeds going to health.
Unfortunately, what we do now is either play a shell game with costs or reduce services and resources from the groups that squeak the least. Both of these are unacceptable. The reality is that since we want to provide more people with health care and we want better care for all, total costs will increase.
If we want more, then we will have to accept that our total costs will be more too.
How do we raise revenue or reduce costs? Here are seven areas to consider:
1. Increase the tax on tobacco and alcohol with proceeds going to health. (Disincentives for smoking, including citywide smoking bans, have been proven to work.)
2. Enforce clean air and clean water laws.
3. Make companies pay for health consequences of their actions.
4. Encourage widespread use of health information technology.
5. Use mobile phone/messaging systems to support consumers in managing their own health.
6. Reinvent the school nurse/clinic model.
7. Create luxury taxes with proceeds going to health.
Unfortunately, what we do now is either play a shell game with costs or reduce services and resources from the groups that squeak the least. Both of these are unacceptable. The reality is that since we want to provide more people with health care and we want better care for all, total costs will increase.
If we want more, then we will have to accept that our total costs will be more too.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)